Doctor Who, Features

Doctor Who in 2012

tumblr_l3eustX71h1qbkiyvo1_500

As we leave 2012, one of the worst years Doctor Who has had in an awfully long time, and enter the 50th anniversary year of 2013, it’s worth taking a look at where and why the show has been going so very wrong lately, and we will be doing so by standing on the shoulders (and nicking the best ideas) of former authors of Doctor Who novels from the ’90s. Long-time readers will know that your correspondent is a fan of the writings (if not necessarily the opinions) of Lawrence Miles, a curmudgeon of some repute in the Who fan community. Miles is also one of the most astute critics of modern Who (or was, before he stopped watching) and though he had a personal conflict with Stephen Moffat which might have coloured his opinions on the latter’s reign somewhat, he has been consistently correct about the show’s downward plummet in quality of late, and the nature thereof (though he called perhaps it a little too early). Lawrence Miles was right, ladies and gentlemen.

Continue reading

Standard
Doctor Who, Reviews, TV

Review: Doctor Who: The Girl Who Waited

Well worth the wait.
Continue reading

Standard
Features, One A Day, Reviews, TV

Review: Sherlock


I’m quite fond of Sherlock Holmes: the books are great and the Basil Rathbone films have a rather endearing quality. I haven’t seen much of it, but I’m told the Guy Ritchie film starring Iron Man and Sky Captain is rather good as well. So, by all accounts, an adaptation set in the modern day with the primary creative forces behind it being Steven ‘Doctor Who’ Moffatt (and slightly less encouragingly, Mark ‘I Suppose Nebulous Was Quite Good’ Gatiss) and starring Benedict Cumberbatch (who punched Mark Kermode for being rude about Ikea Knightly) and Martin Freeman (who was in that awful H2G2 film), and moreover written by the aforementioned Mr Moffat must be good. Right? (spoilers, by the way)
Continue reading

Standard
Doctor Who, One A Day, Reviews, TV

Review: Doctor Who: The Big Bang


It seems like years since I sat down to pen my review of the Eleventh Hour – Matt Smith still unproven as a Doctor, next to nothing known about Amy Pond, and the cracks in time a mystery. Now… well, things are different. I don’t know exactly what I was expecting… but it wasn’t what just happened. As for my full and frank opinion on what just happened, well, just click the link, but really, really spoilers from the start. Really really really. I mean it. If you haven’t watched the episode yet, don’t read further. Just don’t. Seriously, don’t.
Continue reading

Standard
Doctor Who, One A Day, Reviews, TV

Review: Doctor Who: The Pandorica Opens

Never ignore a coincidence. Unless you’re busy, in which case, always ignore a coincidence

There’s been something missing from this series of Doctor Who. A couple of things, actually. Beyond the odd glimpse here and there, special effects have been remarkably underused. Leaving aside the money shots in Victory, other than a few monsters, ships and a space whale, we haven’t had nearly as many special effects as usual. Loads of special-effect-light episodes – Amy’s Choice, Vincent and the Doctor, The Lodger… hell, even the Silurian two-parter didn’t really have that many. The other thing that’s been missing is good monsters. We’ve had the Angels, and… yeah, that’s pretty much it. Prisoner Zero, Power-ranger Daleks, fish-monsters, the stupid Silurians and the giant invisible turkey (and a hologram). So, this episode seems to remedy most of these deficiencies by having special effects every other cutaway and monsters up the wazoo. It looks like they decided to go all-out for the finale. Was it worth it? Click the link to find out!
Continue reading

Standard
Doctor Who, Features, One A Day, Reviews, TV

Review: Doctor Who: Flesh and Stone


Flesh and Stone is a rather interesting episode, because it tries to balance the need to do justice to the angels themselves and fulfil the obligations it has to the Big Overarching Story. It was done fairly well, and I’m tempted to forgive it because it’s so well-written, it has such panache, but I’m not in the business of leniancy, I’m in the business of criticism. That said, this was probably the best episode since the first in the series. The shift in focus about half-way through is a little jarring, but the episode itself has so many good ideas, it redeems itself. As usual, spoilers from the beginning.
Continue reading

Standard
Doctor Who, Features, One A Day, TV

Review: Doctor Who: The Beast Below

Thank goodness! I was afraid that Grand Moff Steven wouldn’t be able to keep on going, but somehow he managed it! Another great episode, even if at times it did feel like a hotchpotch of ideas from other places… but I’ll get to that. This blog post will contain strong spoilers from the very beginning, so readers of a sensitive disposition may wish to look away now.
Continue reading

Standard
Doctor Who, One A Day, Reviews, TV, Writing

Review: Doctor Who: The Eleventh Hour.


I’m going to restrain my emotion, and phrase the opening paragraph in such a way that until you click the ‘read more’ link, you won’t know what I thought about this, Series 31, Episode 1 (The Eleventh Hour) of Doctor Who, and Matt Smith’s first whole episode. New showrunner, Doctor, TARDIS and sonic screwdriver. (I’m trying really hard to restrain myself here) Hit the jump to find out what I thought about the latest episode of Doctor Who. Oh, and spoilers, if you haven’t seen it.
Continue reading

Standard